I don’t know about you, but I find all the ins and outs of piano technique fascinating.
I love that Glenn Gould could sit well below the keyboard in a position that most teachers would denounce as pretty appalling and still achieve incredible performances and be revered for evermore.
I love the flat-fingered and barely-moving but perfect technique of Horowitz that wowed audiences for years.
I love that UK organist Richard Hill (whom I heard perform in Australia at the end of last year and noted as one of the world’s best organists) played amazingly but with a collapsed pinky that most teachers would find hard to ignore (hard to see in this video):
No doubt you’ve seen other competent performers play with raised pinkies or overly-curled fingers – something that, as a teacher, you would have corrected (and probably spent a lot of time correcting!).
How is it that so many different approaches to technique can have such great outcomes? Why are piano teachers so convinced that there should only be one way to train a student? Why do we pounce on weak joints and flat fingers and odd seating positions when it doesn’t necessarily have an impact on the sound?
An example: Thumb under
As an example, I was discussing with my staff at the end of last year how thumb movement under the hand (eg. in scales) should be taught.
Should we teach them to start moving the thumb under the hand immediately after it has played, should we focus on rotation to keep the thumb in position or should we just let the movement of the hand up the piano at higher speeds dictate the new position of the thumb (eg. Chopin Etude Op 10 no 1)?
Of course, each teacher had their own opinion, most often based on how they themselves were taught.
Here are a couple of examples of these different approaches.
Thumb under (Graham Fitch)
Rotation (Edna Golandsky)
Which is the right way? How long is a piece of string!?
Is there a right way to look at piano technique?
Of course, there is no “right way” when it comes to teaching piano technique because everyone is different, hands are different and teaching backgrounds are varied.
However, there are some standard practices to which pianists and teachers have generally agreed over the years and which seems to produce an effective outcome in performance. For example, leaving Gould aside, there is a generally accepted convention about how to sit for greatest control and mobility and 99% of pianists seem to follow this convention.
It’s also generally agreed that the last joint of fingers should be strong and not bend backwards to achieve the greatest control over tone and touch. Similarly, it is agreed that the hand should keep a naturally curved shape when playing.
But after that, things become open to interpretation: are scales and arpeggios important? (See my post Are Scales Irrelevant? for more thoughts on this) How do you move the thumb? What if your student is flat fingered? How do you play Chopin Etudes without pain and injury? etc. etc.
John Bloomfield and the Taubman Approach
I think the Chopin Etude example is a great one as I myself have struggled managing the technical aspects of Op 10 No 1. How do you play such widely spaced arpeggios at speed and with volume for an extended time without breaking your hands? How do you play long runs of double octaves without pain?
With all the above in mind, I was excited to interview Taubman teacher and co-founder of the Golandsky Institute, John Bloomfield, who is presenting this weekend at the Taubman Workshops in Brisbane. One of the lectures being presented is Edna Golandsky herself on “Unravelling the Chopin Etudes”.
Here’s an interview I just did with keynote presenter, John Bloomfield about piano technique what to expect this weekend (please excuse the quality of my microphone):
If you’re not going to be in Brisbane, you can also get online access to the workshops until March 31. Check out the full details here.
Subscribers can get $10 off 1-day registration and $20 off 2-day registrations using the codes on the event page.
What do you think?
How do you teach thumb-under in scales? Have you experienced pain in your playing? What scales and exercises do you use? Got any great piano technique tips? Leave a comment below.
The History of Piano Technique: Studies and Exercises | Graham Fitch
Spin the wheel! I’ve recently been having fun with my students using a nifty little app called DecideNow. I posted about it a while ago on my Facebook page, but thought a quick little 2-minute video might be the best way to explain how I actually use it in my studio. Have fun with it and let me ... Quick Video: Making Scales Fun with DecideNow!
TTTV070: Avoiding Pianistic Injury with Dr Bronwen Ackermann
by Tim Topham
How much importance do you place on technique in your studio? Chances are if you’ve experienced a pianistic injury yourself you consider your technique teaching very carefully. It can be hard to undo bad habits we get into through years of study. Playing an instrument is a physical task, but we don’t often think about ... TTTV070: Avoiding Pianistic Injury with Dr Bronwen Ackermann
If you’ve got holidays coming up or have some students that could do with some fresh technical work, check out these ideas. I personally like to give my students different things to do in order to break up their usual menu of scales and arpeggios and the holidays seem like a perfect chance! Of course, mixing ... Holiday Piano Technical Work Ideas
TTTV003: What does a healthy piano technique mean to me? [Panel Discussion]
by Tim Topham
A group chat with three people from around Australia and USA, this podcast delves into people’spersonal experience with piano technique and in particular, how the Taubman approach can be so important in developing an effortless, comfortable approach to piano technique. My guests today are: Annie Buettner-Moore – Piano/Sax performer and teacher from Perth, WA Leo ... TTTV003: What does a healthy piano technique mean to me? [Panel Discussion]
Tim Topham is the founder and director of TopMusic. Tim hosts the popular Integrated Music Teaching Podcast, blogs regularly at dev.topmusic.co and speaks at local and international conferences on topics such as integrated teaching, creativity, business, marketing and entrepreneurship. Tim has been featured in American Music Teacher, The Piano Teacher Magazine, California Music Teacher and EPTA Piano Professional. Tim holds an MBA in Educational Leadership, BMus, DipEd and AMusA.
We use cookies to optimise our website and our service. You can change your settings from the cookie declaration page.
Functional cookies
Always active
The technical storage or access is strictly necessary for the legitimate purpose of enabling the use of a specific service explicitly requested by the subscriber or user, or for the sole purpose of carrying out the transmission of a communication over an electronic communications network.
Preferences
The technical storage or access is necessary for the legitimate purpose of storing preferences that are not requested by the subscriber or user.
Statistics
The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for statistical purposes.The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for anonymous statistical purposes. Without a subpoena, voluntary compliance on the part of your Internet Service Provider, or additional records from a third party, information stored or retrieved for this purpose alone cannot usually be used to identify you.
Marketing
The technical storage or access is required to create user profiles to send advertising, or to track the user on a website or across several websites for similar marketing purposes.
Share